Mayor Michael Bloomberg and his health conscious movement fizzled out yesterday with a ruling claiming that the proposed NYC soda portion ban was beyond the scope of the powers of the mayor. 

This hits at a larger issue: at what point are our freedoms being infringed upon in the name of public health? 

Bloomberg's crusade against salt, smoking, noise, trans fats, and now soda is ill conceived. People should always be allowed to make their own choices, even though it may harm their health. 

The slippery slope of Bloomberg's logic is dangerous. If large sugary drinks are banned, what about packages of cookies? M&Ms? Peanuts? Large containers of peanut butter sold at Costco? Whole pizzas? Ice cream? No more 'gotta have it' at Cold Stone? 

No matter how well intentioned, the government should seek to inform and then let people make their choices. After all, stupidity cannot be legislated out of existence. Government should protect people from violence and harm, but harm against themselves? It is just silly.

Perhaps the Mayor would be better served by focusing on the crumbling infrastructure around the city, solving traffic problems, and coordinating with the MTA on reforming its system so that it can modernize without pricing people out of the city. 
Anonymous
3/12/2013 09:26:23 am

Yes people can make their own decisions, but don't you feel in the super sized world we live that it's got to the point where it's too much!

Reply
Anonymous
3/17/2013 03:56:03 am

Everything is too much in our society. But there are larger evils than sugar that are contributing to the overall decline in health - why not make smoking illegal? Why not ban happy hours? I would argue that cigarettes and alcohol are equally or even more destructive than super size soda drinks. I'm not advocating for the ban on cigarettes or alcohol but I just think that people should be allowed to choose what they put into their body - whether it be bad or good for us. It's our freedom to choose and government should not dictate what we can and cannot eat/drink.

Reply
Daniel D'Aniello
3/17/2013 04:34:21 am

Yes, it is too much but I do believe that people need to then not buy the products. If we demand smaller portions, then producers would reflect those wishes.

Reply

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    Author

    Daniel is an author, freelance writer, blogger, and content creator. He lives in Brooklyn, NY.

    Archives

    April 2013
    March 2013

    Categories

    All
    Brooklyn
    Dog
    Dowager Countess
    Downton Abbey
    Financial System
    Fitbit
    Food
    Gdp
    Health
    Maggie Smith
    Manners
    Puppy
    Stock Market
    United States